Tata Punch EV vs MG Astor — Which One is the Better Pick?
Both the Tata Punch EV and MG Astor sit in the same segment and are often on the same shortlist for buyers. They are close on price, similar in size, but quite different when you dig into the details.
Here is a full breakdown across specs, mileage, dimensions and safety to help you see those differences clearly.
| Key Highlights | Tata Punch EV | MG Astor |
|---|---|---|
| On Road Price | Rs.9.99 L* | Rs.9.79 L* |
| Fuel Type | Electric | Petrol |
| Battery Capacity | 25 kWh | 1498cc |
| Transmission | Automatic | Manual |
Pros & Cons
Tata Punch EV
Things We Like
- •Looks better: Subtle changes to the design had made it look more modern and bigger than before.
- •More range: Both battery packs are not bigger which offer better real-world range than before
- •Keeps you comfortable: The ride quality over speed breakers and potholes is plush and it handles well too
- •Value for money: Gets a well-rounded package at a lower price than before. The BaaS pricing also makes it more accessible.
Things We Don't Like
- •A 4 Seater: There is limited space for 5 passengers in the back and the middle passenger does not get a headrest
- •Needs rear seat convenience: Rear passengers also miss out on rear AC vents and cupholders
MG Astor
Things We Like
- •Premium Interior: Sporty dashboard design with good-quality materials that give the cabin an upmarket feel.
- •Good Features: Gets a 10.1-inch touchscreen, 7-inch digital driver’s display, ADAS, and an AI assistant.
- •Refined And Powerful: The turbo-petrol engine feels smooth, has low vibrations, and offers strong performance.
Things We Don't Like
- •Average Mileage: Fuel efficiency is not the strongest in its segment.
- •Engine Feels Relaxed: Not very exciting for performance-focused buyers.
- •No Diesel Option: Available only with petrol engine options.
Tata Punch EV vs MG Astor — What the Numbers Tell You
The Tata Punch EV and MG Astor are two of the more talked-about options in the segment in India right now. Both have their own strengths and both attract a similar kind of buyer — someone who wants a well-rounded car without spending too much.
On the engine front, the Tata Punch EV comes with a while the MG Astor runs on a . The power and torque figures are close, but the real-world driving feel of the two is noticeably different. The Tata Punch EV leans more towards a smoother, comfort-focused experience while the MG Astor feels more planted and direct.
When it comes to dimensions, the Tata Punch EV measures in length and offers litres of boot space. The MG Astor on the other hand is long with a -litre boot. For buyers who regularly carry luggage or travel with family, this gap can actually matter in everyday use.
Mileage is often the first thing buyers ask about, and both cars deliver competitive figures for their segment. The Tata Punch EV returns 275 as per ARAI ratings, while the MG Astor is rated at 275. Real-world numbers will always be lower depending on how and where you drive, but the gap between them stays largely consistent.
On safety, both cars come with . However, the top variants of each bring in additional features — making it important to compare specific trims rather than just base models when safety is a priority.
Pricing for the Tata Punch EV starts at ₹9.99 L and goes up to ₹14.44 L, while the MG Astor is priced from ₹9.79 Lto ₹15.50 L.
At the end of the day, both the Tata Punch EV and MG Astor are solid options in their segment. The right pick depends on what matters more to you — features, mileage, brand trust or simply how the car feels to drive. Use the comparison tool above to go deeper into any specific variant or spec that matters most to your decision.
For the latest prices, offers and updates on the Tata Punch EV and MG Astor, keep following CarBike4U.
More Tata Punch EV Comparisons
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Citroen Basalt
₹8.15 - 13.11 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Citroen Aircross
₹8.29 - 13.69 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Volkswagen Taigun
₹11.42 - 19.19 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Nissan Magnite
₹5.62 - 10.96 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Renault Kiger
₹5.76 - 10.34 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Skoda Kushaq
₹10.66 - 18.49
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Skoda Kylaq
₹7.59 - 12.99 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
MG Hector
₹11.99 - 18.99 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Honda Elevate
₹11.6 - 16.67 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Mahindra XUV 3XO EV
₹13.89 - 14.96 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Mahindra Bolero Neo Plus
₹10.77 - 11.8 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Mahindra Bolero Neo
₹8.49 - 10.49 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Mahindra Thar ROXX
₹12.39 - 22.25 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Mahindra XUV 3XO
₹7.37 - 14.55 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Mahindra Bolero
₹7.99 - 9.69 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Mahindra Scorpio
₹12.98 - 16.7 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Mahindra Thar
₹9.99 - 16.99 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Hyundai Venue N Line
₹10.65 - 15.58 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Hyundai Exter
₹5.64 - 9.61 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Hyundai Venue
₹8 - 15.69 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Hyundai Creta
₹10.79 - 20.2 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Toyota Taisor
₹7.25 - 12.39 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Toyota Urban Cruiser Hyryder
₹10.99 - 19.99 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Kia Syros
₹8.67 - 15.94 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Kia Sonet
₹7.3 - 14 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Kia Seltos
₹10.99 - 19.99 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Tata Nexon EV
₹12.49 - 17.49 Lakh
Tata Curvv
₹9.66 - 18.85 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Tata Harrier
₹12.89 - 25.25 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Tata Nexon
₹7.32 - 14.15 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Tata Sierra
₹11.49 - 21.29 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Tata Punch
₹5.6 - 10.55 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Maruti Jimny
₹12.31 - 14.45 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Maruti Victoris
₹10.5 - 19.99 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Maruti Grand Vitara
₹10.77 - 19.72 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Maruti Brezza
₹8.26 - 13.01 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
Maruti FRONX
₹6.85 - 11.98 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
More MG Astor Comparisons
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Maruti e Vitara
₹15.99 - 20.01 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Citroen Basalt
₹8.15 - 13.11 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Citroen Aircross
₹8.29 - 13.69 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Volkswagen Taigun
₹11.42 - 19.19 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Nissan Magnite
₹5.62 - 10.96 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Renault Kiger
₹5.76 - 10.34 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Skoda Kushaq
₹10.66 - 18.49
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Skoda Kylaq
₹7.59 - 12.99 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
MG Hector Plus
₹17.29 - 19.49 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
MG ZS EV
₹17.99 - 20.5 Lakh
MG Hector
₹11.99 - 18.99 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Honda Elevate
₹11.6 - 16.67 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Mahindra XUV 3XO EV
₹13.89 - 14.96 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Mahindra Bolero Neo Plus
₹10.77 - 11.8 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Mahindra XUV400 EV
₹15.49 - 17.69 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Mahindra Bolero Neo
₹8.49 - 10.49 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Mahindra XUV 7XO
₹13.66 - 24.92 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Mahindra Thar ROXX
₹12.39 - 22.25 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Mahindra XUV 3XO
₹7.37 - 14.55 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Mahindra Bolero
₹7.99 - 9.69 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Mahindra Scorpio
₹12.98 - 16.7 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Mahindra Thar
₹9.99 - 16.99 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Mahindra Scorpio N
₹13.2 - 24.17 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Hyundai Creta N Line
₹17.83 - 20.09 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Hyundai Venue N Line
₹10.65 - 15.58 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Hyundai Alcazar
₹14.5 - 21.2 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Hyundai Venue
₹8 - 15.69 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Hyundai Creta
₹10.79 - 20.2 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Toyota Taisor
₹7.25 - 12.39 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Toyota Urban Cruiser Hyryder
₹10.99 - 19.99 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Kia Syros
₹8.67 - 15.94 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Kia Sonet
₹7.3 - 14 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Kia Seltos
₹10.99 - 19.99 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Tata Nexon EV
₹12.49 - 17.49 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Tata Punch EV
₹9.69 - 12.59 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Tata Curvv
₹9.66 - 18.85 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Tata Harrier
₹12.89 - 25.25 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Tata Safari
₹13.29 - 25.96 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Tata Nexon
₹7.32 - 14.15 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Tata Sierra
₹11.49 - 21.29 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Tata Punch
₹5.6 - 10.55 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Maruti Jimny
₹12.31 - 14.45 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Maruti Victoris
₹10.5 - 19.99 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Maruti Grand Vitara
₹10.77 - 19.72 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Maruti Brezza
₹8.26 - 13.01 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh
Maruti FRONX
₹6.85 - 11.98 Lakh
MG Astor
₹9.79 - 15.5 Lakh